Skip to main content

Table 2 Chi-square fit values for previously non-fitting datasets, disaggregated in to original experimental conditions

From: Do sequential lineups impair underlying discriminability?

Dataset

Simultaneous lineup

Sequential lineup

SDT-MAX

SDT-INT

SDT-SEQ

SDT-INT

Carlson et al. (2008, Exp 2) – biased

19.68*

19.66*

1.94

22.76*

Carlson et al. (2008, Exp 2) – intermediate

.81

3.02

.42

10.23*

Carlson et al. (2008, Exp 2) – fair

10.00*

16.88*

.85

2.61

Greathouse and Kovera (2009) – biased, single-blind

.15

.38

.78

.15

Greathouse and Kovera (2009) – biased, double-blind

.57

.38

4.08

2.17

Greathouse and Kovera (2009) – fair, single-blind

5.44

6.29

4.06

.44

Greathouse and Kovera (2009) – fair, double-blind

3.83

4.09

.25

.15

Pozzulo and Marciniak (2006) – no appearance change

.89

.09

1.82

3.81

Pozzulo and Marciniak (2006) –appearance changed

.21

.06

12.60*

11.58*

  1. *Non-fitting datasets: asterisks indicate a significant difference from zero, Îħ = 0.01 (critical value = 6.63)