Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications

Table 1 Wetmore et al. (2015) simultaneous lineup and showup data collapsed over retention interval and lineup fairness accompanied by WITNESS predictions

From: The impact of fillers on lineup performance

		Wetmore et al. (2015)		WITNESS
		Target present	Target absent	Target present	Target absent
Showup	Suspect ID	.593	.413	.593	.111
Showup	Rejection	.407	.587	.407	.889
Lineup	Suspect ID	.733	.196	.756	.202
	Filler ID	.087	.421	.110	.453
	Rejection	.180	.382	.134	.345

Target-absent lineup suspect ID rates are italicized to highlight the large degree of mis-fit in the WITNESS model in these cells
ID identification

Back to article page